Nature comment questions AI consciousness and computational functionalism
What happened
On 8 November 2026, The Decoder reported that three scholars questioned the metaphor of the brain as a computer in a Nature comment article, arguing that computational functionalism has fundamental flaws and that current AI systems are not conscious. The article cites an assessment report by Butlin et al. covering 14 indicators, which judged that existing systems, including GPT-4, are not strong candidates for consciousness and found only weak signs in language models. The authors also cite AlphaFold as an example, noting that a powerful neural network is not thereby conscious.
Written by AI from the reports · updated 7 d ago
Timeline
Follow the reports to see the event from each side.
- The DecoderThe brain-as-computer metaphor shaped modern AI but may be misleading the consciousness debate
Consciousness researchers Anil Seth, Ned Block, and Giulio Tononi argue in a Nature commentary that today's AI systems aren't conscious and won't become so on silicon hardware. They consider the assumption that consciousness depends on computation alone "fatally flawed" and warn against granting rights to AI systems.
Heat of this event
Current heat 3·Peak in the comparable range 7(Nov 9 09:00)·Change over 24 hours in the comparable range -49%
The trend compares only the same accounts observed without a break, so its range can be narrower than the current heat count. Move the pointer or tap the chart to see each hour; with a keyboard, use the left and right arrow keys.